NGSS Resources
  • My NGSS Blog
  • Assessment Resources
  • Resources and links
  • Science and Engineering Practices
  • Crosscutting Concepts
  • Student Growth and the NGSS
  • About Me

Explaining Phenomena?  What does that look like?

3/29/2015

17 Comments

 
April 2016 Update:  Since this blog was first published, TJ McKenna has created a site listing several phenomena that can be used in NGSS-aligned instruction. It can also be used to inspire you to think of your own phenomena.  Check his site out at ​http://www.ngssphenomena.com_/ 

The intent of the NGSS is summed up in one sentence in the EQuIP Rubric (a tool that can be used to evaluate lessons and units to see if they align with the NGSS): "Grade-appropriate elements of the science and engineering practice(s), disciplinary core idea(s), and crosscutting concept(s), work together to support students in three-dimensional learning to make sense of phenomena and/or to design solutions to problems."  This statement should be hanging in bold print near each of our desks to remind us of the goal when we are planning instruction.  

One of the challenges that this vision presents is finding the phenomena around which to build my instruction.

I feel like my colleagues and I have done a decent job designing hands-on instruction that aligns with the DCIs and science and engineering practices.  I have good intentions to incorporate the crosscutting concepts next year.  However, the idea of explaining phenomena that are relevant and important to students trips me up.  

My current unit revolves around waves, light, and digital signals.  We've done a lot of hands-on activities that help students understand how to model waves and connections between aspects of waves (frequency, amplitude, etc.) and events they experience (color of light, volume of sound, etc.), but we haven't looked at a big relevant phenomenon that students can use their new knowledge to explain.  One of my colleagues suggested that next year we frame this unit around "a day at the beach."  Were we not in landlocked central Kentucky, a field trip to the beach would be a great way to start the unit.  This will be an area of concentration for me next year as I work to refine the units I taught this year.  I'll be working to find those phenomena that interest students to use as anchors for our instruction and hands-on activities.  

This is also one of those occasions where it is imperative that teachers and administrators understand the intent of the Framework and align our instruction to it.  Just saying we teach about waves and do hands-on activities to go with it doesn't mean that we're hitting the intent of the standards.  If we aren't providing experiences that help students explain phenomena that are relevant to them, then we are missing an important component of the standards.  
17 Comments
Kim Weber
3/29/2015 06:22:30 am

We were just having this conversation at the Kentucky Science Leadership Network meeting in Lexington this past week. The NGSS standards are meant to be "phenomena-based". This was a major "a-ha" moment for me, that the big picture of each unit is not a topic, or any single learning target, but a phenomena whose mystery can be understood using scientific thinking.

Reply
David
3/29/2015 06:27:44 am

Kim--I don't feel like that idea is evident in the standards or the Framework as much as it is in the EQuIP rubric. That's just one more paradigm shift that we have to embrace and share with our colleagues and administrators. One challenge is going to be aligning all of the learning under that phenomenon. To me, it's a bit like an essential question.

Reply
Christine
4/14/2015 02:31:39 pm

We really need to communicate this aspect of the NGSS! I would be so cool if we could create a list of phenomenon (not exhaustive of course!) that align with the grade level PEs! Shall we dig in? We could present possible ideas in the Science Connection and then ask for teachers to submit their ideas. What do you think????>

Reply
Cathy
2/17/2016 07:30:52 am

Christine , I love your idea ! I think sharing the information and strategies with each other will assist us in helping our students . You may bring a point to the group or help someone in the group who are having difficulty clarifying information to their class . What a better way to receive help, by sharing

Reply
Erik Elstad link
4/5/2016 06:21:08 pm

I find matching the phenomenon to the standard a challenge myself. On my website I have a few to share.

Lori
4/6/2016 06:07:26 am

YES please. Since we all have to find meaningful phenomena, it would be amazing to have a list of ideas for EACH standard. I am tired of searching the internet for mediocre ideas that I am not quite sure even fit.

Reply
Marsha Ratzel link
4/21/2015 09:24:54 am

I loved your post when you said, " Were we not in landlocked central Kentucky, a field trip to the beach would be a great way to start the unit. " Since I'm from Kansas, I totally feel the same way.
But what if we looked at different kinds of waves. I was watching some crazy TV when I saw something called an Earth Harp being played on a talent show. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ERjE22bwFcA is a Youtube video of it.

Wouldn't this be something that students could do? maybe collect sounds, analyzing their waves and then try to create an instrument that they could play? I know it focuses on sound and doesn't really take into account light so it may not work at all.

I think it would be engaging. Maybe. :-} Really I've been thinking and thinking on this since I taught it last year and still haven't come up with a great idea.

Reply
Shawn Knaack
8/13/2015 01:21:12 am

Wouldn't it be nice to have a comprehensive list of phenomena? Here's a place to add MS NGSS Phenomena.http://goo.gl/7fce0H Started by David Grossman @tksciguy

Reply
Christine
8/17/2015 02:56:15 am

Reply
Sara
10/23/2015 09:02:33 am

Thanks for sharing this experience and struggle. Our site is in the beginning stages of implementation and desperately searching for ideas for phenomenon to build units around. Have you found resources to help you with finding phenomenon? Also, in the comments there's a Google doc that the commenter wrote is for generating a list of phenomenon. I can't access the doc. Has anyone been successful with it?

Reply
Megan
2/4/2016 11:12:25 am

The Ambitious Science Teaching group at the University of Washington has done a lot of work around this. The link below is a "primer" on how to identify the big ideas of a unit and select a strong phenomenon to organize the unit around.
http://ambitiousscienceteaching.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/Primer-Plannning-for-Engagement.pdf

Reply
David
2/4/2016 06:49:05 pm

Thanks so much for sharing this. It looks like a great resource. I can't wait to dive into it.

Reply
Ashley
1/1/2017 10:10:30 pm

Thank you! The document was a great resource to give more explanation of how to create a strong phenomenon. It also shows how it all connects together with the what students are suppose to get out of it. Again, thank you for sharing.

Reply
Rich Bacolor link
2/7/2016 09:52:32 am

Hey all - I'm moderating the #miscichat Twitter chat around the topic of phenomenon based science teaching tomorrow night at (2/8/2016) 8:30 EST. Please stop in and add your valuable thoughts.

Reply
Sharon Moats
2/22/2016 08:28:38 pm

Hi Rich,

How did your Twitter chat around phenomena go? Any new insights?
Sharon from NGSx

Reply
David
4/6/2016 09:14:21 pm

Since this blog was first published, TJ McKenna has created a website dedicated to identifying phenomena. You may find phenomena you can use at his site, or you may be inspired by what you find there. Check out his site at http://www.ngssphenomena.com/

Reply
Kailey Rhodes link
9/26/2016 07:23:16 pm

Great post! We recently hosted TJ McKenna in a webinar surrounding phenomena! He is AWESOME. We also recently had a webinar introducing the NGSS from Level Zero. We've found that a lot of teachers just need to press the reset button and learn about the NGSS with a fresh perspective!

TJ's Webinar:
https://www.rubicon.com/ngss-using-phenomena-engage-students/

More NGSS Resources (including our "Level Zero" webinar): https://www.rubicon.com/ngss-resource-round/

Please continue to write about your NGSS journey—we all benefit from it!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    August 2021
    June 2021
    December 2020
    August 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    November 2018
    October 2018
    October 2017
    June 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    November 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    October 2014
    September 2014
    July 2014

    Categories

    All
    3 Dimensional Learning
    3-dimensional Learning
    ALP
    Communicate
    Gather
    Models
    NGSS
    #NGSSblogs
    Notebook
    Reading
    Reason
    Science And Engineering Practices
    Storyline
    Writing

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.